Beta Free full access during beta. All models, tools, and daily picks included.
Game-Day Update Lineups: Projected Odds Posted 6 min read

Milwaukee Brewers vs St. Louis Cardinals Preview

Milwaukee Brewers visit St. Louis Cardinals at 7:45 PM ET. Brandon Sproat (6.75 ERA) faces Andre Pallante (3.73 ERA) at Busch Stadium

Milwaukee Brewers at St. Louis Cardinals MLB game preview for May 5, 2026
MIL
Milwaukee Brewers
Brandon Sproat RHP
@
7:45 PM ET
Busch Stadium
STL
St. Louis Cardinals
Andre Pallante RHP
Last updated Tuesday, May 5, 2026

Key Facts

Matchup
Milwaukee Brewers at St. Louis Cardinals
Date
Tuesday, May 5, 2026
First Pitch
7:45 PM ET
Venue
Busch Stadium
Probable Starters
Brandon Sproat (RHP) vs Andre Pallante (RHP)
Lineups
Projected
Odds Snapshot
May 5, 7:46 PM ET
Last Updated
May 5, 7:08 AM ET

Betting Board

Snapshot May 5, 7:46 PM ET
Moneyline
MIL -105
STL -105
Total
Over 7.5 -118
Under 7.5 -104
Run Line
MIL -1.5 +164
STL +1.5 -200

Model Angles

NRFI Model
NRFI · 60%
+5.6% edge
Projected Total
5.1
model combined runs
Park Factor
1.01
Neutral · HR 1.04
First Pitch Weather
50°F
8.7 mph N
The Milwaukee Brewers visit the St. Louis Cardinals at Busch Stadium for a 7:45 PM ET first pitch. Milwaukee enters at 18-16 following a two-game losing streak, while St. Louis sits at 21-14 after winning its last game. Brandon Sproat takes the mound for the Brewers with a 6.75 ERA, 1.61 WHIP, and 8.44 strikeouts per nine innings. Andre Pallante counters for the Cardinals, posting a 3.73 ERA, 1.31 WHIP, and 7.47 strikeouts per nine. The projected total stands at 5.1 runs, with Milwaukee projected for 2.7 and St. Louis for 2.4. Sproat is projected for 3.9 strikeouts against a line of 4.5, while Pallante projects to 4.2 strikeouts versus a 3.5 line. The no run first inning probability sits at 61 percent. Weather calls for 50 degrees with 11 mph winds from the north. The park factor is 1.01 runs.
  • Sproat brings 6.75 ERA and 1.61 WHIP to Busch Stadium
  • Cardinals 21-14 and winners of one straight facing Brewers
  • NRFI probability registers at 61 percent with 7.0 percent edge

Pitching Matchup

MIL Away
Brandon Sproat
RHP · 0-2 · 4 GS
ERA
6.75
WHIP
1.61
K/9
8.44
IP
26.2
Career: 5.89 ERA · 1.44 WHIP · 7.99 K/9
STL Home
Andre Pallante
RHP · 3-2 · 6 GS
ERA
3.73
WHIP
1.31
K/9
7.47
IP
31.1
Career: 4.29 ERA · 1.41 WHIP · 6.36 K/9
NRFI: 77.8%
1st Inn ERA: 4.50

On the season, Andre Pallante holds the ERA edge in this matchup. Brandon Sproat carries a 6.75 ERA and 1.61 WHIP, while Andre Pallante sits at 3.73 ERA and 1.31 WHIP.
Strikeout rates: Brandon Sproat at 8.44 K/9, Andre Pallante at 7.47 K/9.
K projections: Brandon Sproat at 3.7 (line 4.5)
Andre Pallante projected at 4.2 (line 3.5).
Andre Pallante has a 77.8% career NRFI rate. No first-inning data available for Brandon Sproat.
Both starters throw from the R side, limiting platoon splits for either lineup.

Strikeout Projections

Brandon Sproat vs STL
Proj: 3.7Line: 4.5
-0.8
Confidence:
Andre Pallante vs MIL
Proj: 4.2Line: 3.5
+0.7
Confidence:
View all K projections on SlateIQ

Our strikeout model weighs pitcher K rate, opponent lineup whiff tendency, park factors, and umpire zone size to project total strikeouts per starter.

Brandon Sproat (Milwaukee Brewers) is projected for 3.7 strikeouts against a posted line of 4.5. The projection is close to the line with no actionable edge.
He faces a moderate-K lineup that strikes out at 21.6% with a 28.0% whiff rate.

Andre Pallante (St. Louis Cardinals) is projected for 4.2 strikeouts against a posted line of 3.5. The projection is close to the line with no actionable edge.
He faces a high-K lineup that strikes out at 24.7% with a 28.0% whiff rate.

The Milwaukee Brewers lineup is more vulnerable to strikeouts in this matchup. St. Louis Cardinals batters K at 21.6%, Milwaukee Brewers batters at 24.7%.

NRFI & First 5 Analysis

NRFI Model
59.7%
probability of NRFI
+5.6%
market edge
Monitor
Market implied: 54.1%Model: 59.7%
First 5 Innings
2.8est. F5 runs
MIL
6.75 ERA
6.5 inn/start
STL
3.73 ERA
5.2 inn/start
F5 lean: Strong STL
MIL K Projection
Brandon Sproat
3.7proj
Line: 4.5
-0.8 NEUTRAL
Confidence
STL K Projection
Andre Pallante
4.2proj
Line: 3.5
+0.7 NEUTRAL
Confidence
Explore all model projections

Our NRFI model analyzes both starting pitchers' first-inning profiles, the top-of-order hitters in each lineup, the umpire's historical zone, and environmental factors to produce a probability estimate. For this game, the model assigns a 59.7% probability of no runs in the first inning, compared to the market's implied probability of 54.1%.

  • That creates a moderate 5.6% edge on NRFI.
  • The best available line is NRFI -118 / YRFI -104 at FanDuel.

The home plate umpire for this game has not yet been assigned. MLB typically posts assignments the morning of game day. Umpire data will be added automatically once the assignment is posted.
Our NRFI model sits at 41-39 (51.2%) on official picks this season.

Lineup & Matchup Breakdown

Milwaukee Brewers Projected
K%: 24.7
Whiff rate: 28.0%Team page
St. Louis Cardinals Projected
K%: 21.6
Whiff rate: 28.0%Team page
Batter vs Pitcher matchup tool

Lineups are projected as of this writing.

Milwaukee Brewers K vulnerability: 24.7% strikeout rate, 28.0% whiff rate.

St. Louis Cardinals K vulnerability: 21.6% strikeout rate, 28.0% whiff rate.

Ballpark, Weather & Umpire

Busch Stadium
Run Factor1.01
HR Factor1.04
Full park profile
Hourly Game Forecast
50°
7 PM
9 mph
N
50°
8 PM
9 mph
N
50°
9 PM
9 mph
N
50°
10 PM
9 mph
N
  • Busch Stadium carries a 1.01 run factor (neutral).
  • Home run factor: 1.04 — the park neutral for HR power.
  • Park notes: Retractable roof; Relatively neutral dimensions; Gateway Arch viewable from stadium.
  • Roof: Retractable.
  • First pitch forecast: 50F with 9 mph winds from the N. Humidity: 90%.
  • Wind advisory: 9 mph winds from the N may impact fly balls.

Home plate umpire: Not yet assigned. Umpire data will be added once the assignment is posted.

Run Projections & Total

  • Our projection model puts the total at 5.1 combined runs, with Milwaukee Brewers projected for 2.7 and St. Louis Cardinals for 2.4.
  • That's 2.4 runs below the posted total of 7.5, suggesting a lean toward the Under.
  • The run projection is essentially a coin flip between these two teams.
The Bottom Line
The Cardinals host the Brewers with a significant pitching advantage as Pallante's 3.73 ERA faces Sproat's 6.75 mark. The projected total of 5.1 runs reflects two pitchers with contrasting profiles in a neutral park environment. Temperature sits at 50 degrees with moderate winds from the north.
This preview is generated from thecapper.io projection models and publicly available data. All projections are model estimates, not guarantees. Gamble responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-GAMBLER.